⭐ My Rating System (aka: Where AI Video Is Really At)
Before we dive in, two quick notes:
🎞 Shot Planning = The Hidden Final Boss
Even with AI, not planning your shots makes everything 10x harder.
If you’ve never made a film before (I went to film school 🙋♂️), a shot list is basically the visual version of a script. It forces your brain to stop winging it.
⏱️ Music Videos Take Time
A 3–4 minute video can still take forever to piece together. Not as long as shooting for real—but still… a long time.
To help with this, I built something called CineScript Studio—a tool to plan AI videos like a pro. It’s in testing and releasing soon for free. If you want early access, reply to this email. I’ll hook you up.
🎬 The AI Video Apps I Tested (Chaos Included)
Below are my honest takes, full transparency, star ratings, and thoughts after pushing each tool to its limit with our line-dancing Santa.
🟦 1. Runway — ★★★★☆ 3.5/5
The smooth operator with commitment issues.
Runway is the easiest way to get high-quality footage that looks like an actual movie. The downside?
👉 Character consistency is still a mess.
Santa starts looking like a mall Santa… then a rancher… then a guy named Kyle on his lunch break.
As I wrote this, they dropped Gen 4.5, so a leap forward is probably coming.
🎯 Good for: Real filmmaking workflows
⚠️ Watch out for: Characters that evolve like Pokémon mid-scene
🤖 2. Grok/X Video — ★★☆☆☆ 2.5/5
The fastest… and also the most “meh.”
This thing is stupid easy. It might become huge once they add more controls—but right now it's basically “push button → receive vibes.”
🎯 Good for: Quick tests, zero-friction experimenting
⚠️ Watch out for: Not much real control
🎨 3. Midjourney Video — ★★★☆☆ 3.1/5
Image wizards trying to become video directors.
Midjourney is still magic for still images—so if you start your frame there, animating it is chef’s kiss.
But…
👉 Character consistency is even harder here
👉 Controls are limited
👉 All your scenes feel like they’re from different movies
Still, if you already pay for MJ, it’s a fun button to press.
🟣 4. Higgsfield / Freepik Models — ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5/5
The secret weapon.
This combo gives you access to powerful models with shockingly strong character consistency tools.
You pay for the power—some platforms using these models get pricey—but for what you get?
🔥 Easily the strongest option today.
🎯 Good for: Real production, longer scenes, repeatable characters
⚠️ Watch out for: Your credit card bill
🟡 5. Google Flow (Veo 3) — ★★★★☆ 4.6/5
This one made me feel like a real director.
Flow gives you an actual timeline and lets you extend scenes, tweak structure, and build fuller cinematic moments.
It feels like you're editing inside a miniature Hollywood.
🎯 Good for: Anyone who wants control, not just vibes
⚠️ Watch out for: Occasional bizarre facial mutations (Veo loves doing this)
🚀 The Bottom Line
If you are serious about this, stop looking for a "one-click" magic button.
- Plan your shots (use a Shot List).
- Generate your base assets (Midjourney/Minuet).
- Animate with control (Higgsfield or Google Flow).
P.S. I’m serious about CineScript Studio. If you want early access to the API or the tool, hit reply. Let’s build something cool.
/